Racing vs Cruising

Boat talk and general conversation.

Moderator: Moderator

User avatar
Michel
Recognized Old Salt
Posts: 993
Joined: Thu Oct 07, 2010 6:25 pm

Re: Racing vs Cruising

Post by Michel »

"What makes that little boat sail so fast?"
Thanks for your comments Dirk! :)

I don't really think about going fast but I am very conscious about the current vs the wind direction at the place I am sailing in the moment and about keeping my sails breathing well and the heeling in a nominal range.
This keep the boat and the skipper happy and we can make good progress together. ;)

In this video, we can see a faster trimaran trying to pass me but missing on every tacks. My boat, even if she is slower, is doing better upwind against the current. 8-)
https://youtu.be/xLSEEOFdlAw

In this older clip, I catch and pass a 24 footer mainly because her skipper was sheeting to much and I know were the current is weaker!... :) It happens a lot! :? It was also the period when I was sailing boomless! I was great with the old main I had at the time. ;)
https://youtu.be/dzuDkN4G3Ac
Michel Boulet
Ex: "Mari-Bell" Sandpiper 565 (18.5367454 ft)
Now: "Papou" Tanzer 16 dinghy
Montreal
"Let the world say what it will"
~~_/)~~
User avatar
TeamHangingOn
New Contributor
Posts: 13
Joined: Thu Nov 19, 2015 7:19 pm

Re: Racing vs Cruising

Post by TeamHangingOn »

I started racing in SCCA Autocross with a Toyota station wagon in H stock (slowest class). My friends used to joke about my car, "Where's the wife, kids and the dog?" but its what I had, I was getting faster & it was fun. I then moved to road racing bikes (pushing 300 kph) and showroom stock Honda Civics - as I moved up classes it took more and more resources (money and time).
I've always had boats but never raced them in the traditional YC sense; however, like following LeManns or F1 (automobiles) always found the racers and their boats fascinating whether its the America's Cup, Volvo Ocean Race, TransAt, Moths, 505's etc. For me it is about perfecting one's abilities within a prescribed set of rules.
As an engineer, it was building the best solution to meet the rules (I designed and built a commercial formula 440 from a clean sheet of paper as an undergraduate).
As a racer, it was perfecting one's line, sail trim, etc. to increase speed or reduce one's time. I learned early on that I didn't have what it takes to be a professional racer when I watched a regional motorcycle racer put his bike down stripping the last two fingers from his hand only to get up, stop the bleeding by taping his hand with duct (aka racers' 200 mph) tape and gauze so that he could race the remainder of the day and earn enough points to qualify for Nationals. For me it was never about winning - it was fun just to go fast around the track and much safer than doing so on the roads.
Fast forward thirty plus years and along comes the Race to Alaska (a race with few rules - no motors of any kind and don't make us consult our lawyers). I cannot explain the drive to participate other than it pulls at my insides so much so that I entered the 2016 R2AK with the intent of sailing it in a Laser because, like the Toyota station wagon, its what I have... and know. Everyone though I was crazy! Not me, I had a plan, a boat and the drive...
Then out of the blue comes an Etchells 22 and she's my new ride north. Like getting to know one's race car, bike, etc. there's a whole new learning curve (including adjusting one's body memory - that feeling you get in the seat of your pants) to acclimate oneself. The initial solo sail at 35+ knots was uncomfortable at first to say the least - an Etchells likes to heel and feels powered up and on track at 40 degrees - the seat of your pants tells you that she's going over... however, theres no weather helm and she just goes. She's powerful and points upwind like you can't believe and after a few hours at 35+ knots of wind your body adjusts and your mind follows. Its my new normal. Needless to say now that I've been sailing her in anticipation of the R2AK she's becoming my perfect boat - powerful and available without any of the fanciness that translates into additional dollars spent. Mine sits on a hook so I can be sailing in less than an hour.
Now back to racing vs cruising - Dirk pointed me to this discussion because I'm not out to claim the $10k in the R2AK (while I wouldn't turn it down) but simply to participate and in so doing win my own personal race. Like it or not, we're all in our own personal races. Whether we know it, or acknowledge it, there's a finish line for all of us (death). I've spent my life doing the right thing: career, marriage, house, etc. and have come to realize this only after suffering a disability that has disrupted my life to its foundation. Time for a course correction - I'm making the most of what I have left. So in 2016 I'll race to Alaska and enjoy the trip along the way; whether that's getting my boat ready, charting the best course, perfecting sail trim and/or launching a spinnaker solo, or simply enjoying the Inside Passage and making new friends. As a bonus I'm taking the outside of Vancouver Island on my return - I already feel like I'm winning... See you at the finish line.
Follow along at http://www.facebook.com/teamhangingon/ or http://www.r2ak.com
Best,
Michael
Etchells 22 & six smaller boats...
Dirk Visser 166
Regular Contributor
Posts: 159
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2015 11:47 am
Location: Fremont, Ca.
Contact:

Re: Racing vs Cruising

Post by Dirk Visser 166 »

Michel,
I checked out those two clips you linked to, and a few more from your file, and I agree with the positive reviews you are receiving ..though I can only guess and hope for the best about the French ...
Nice work behind the camera and at the helm, a smooth operator in both worlds looks like.
Now, here is my idea for your next level of cinematography: Mari-Bell becomes a peaceful aircraft carrier. Saint Nicholas brings you a camera drone !!
Can you imagine the altitude shots you could put to beautiful
music ? Of course you might have your hands full controlling a boat and helicopter !
Dirk Visser 166
Regular Contributor
Posts: 159
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2015 11:47 am
Location: Fremont, Ca.
Contact:

Re: Racing vs Cruising

Post by Dirk Visser 166 »

Wow, Dude, Michael!
Your story and positive attitude, is this one of a cloud of end points in the small boat learning curve?

Yes, indeed, we are all enroute, in the races of our lives, or at least an unpredictable journey of exploration..you paint an inspiring picture of the evolution of psychology shown in an individual.

The high speed motion infatuation is a well documented persistent phase that often hampers further progress, congratulations on surviving it, though I sense it may have left scars in you, as it did me...
Bottom line though, we are the results of our chapters..
Experience is the best teacher...
It may be the only real one..

Have a happy holiday!
-Dirk
User avatar
Art Haberland
Major Contributor
Posts: 481
Joined: Thu Jan 02, 2014 3:08 pm
Location: The Garden State
Contact:

Re: Racing vs Cruising

Post by Art Haberland »

TeamHangingOn wrote:as I moved up classes it took more and more resources (money and time)..
That is always the issue. It starts out fun.. and as you get better, you want a faster vehicle to work with.. eventually it is more "work" than "fun" and all you are doing to chasing a trophy and bragging rights.

And I do agree about racers being pack critters. I am very much an introvert and a loner, it's why I sail a small boat that does not need a crew
User avatar
TeamHangingOn
New Contributor
Posts: 13
Joined: Thu Nov 19, 2015 7:19 pm

Re: Racing vs Cruising

Post by TeamHangingOn »

Thanks Dirk!
Wishing you a happy holiday also...
Last night it came to me what needs to be discussed and that's the art of being a privateer in the world of commercial racing. I'm not sure if you're a motorcycle fan but check out the Isle of Man TT, one of the most prestigious motorcycle races and also remains the ultimate test of both riders and their machines. In this race, all the big teams compete but the beauty is that privateers still manage to compete by sheer ability alone. If you can, take a lap onboard one of the bikes by searching for Isle of Mann - you can rent the 2015 review for $4.99 on iTunes for a four hour show. If you love racing, you'll love the Isle of Man.
Ok how does this relate to racing boats?
Local racing is all about privateers. There are those who have resources and fancy boats and those who don't. My Etchells is a perfect example: in 2011 she was in the Etchells Worlds in San Diego, she fell off her trailer while being transported in southern California, was damaged and to make a long story short, wound up in Port Ludlow racing with Bondo repairs and lichen growing on her decks... she was still competitive in this anti-establishment form and her former owner took great pride in that fact (but he's a racer and competitive). If you're not familiar with the Etchells class, they're a three-person keel boat typically dry-stored and sailed all over the world by excellent sailors - America's Cup teams even used them for training.
Fast forward to a few months ago - I had a Laser sailboat that I had modified for me to be able to sail and a plan to race her in the R2AK. She was no longer class legal but was a sound boat after I finished with her. Because I don't have wrists any more, I had to cut and install large hatches in her decks fore and aft of the cockpit to repair a separated hull after testing her in 30-35 knot winds in Admiralty Inlet. The good news was that a) my prosthetics worked well enough for me to sail her in high winds, b) she broke with plenty of time to repair her before the 2016 R2AK and c) I now had below deck storage and an additional 200 kgs of buoyancy installed in a durable boat. She's not a pretty boat either but that doesn't matter when you're a privateer with limited resources and a drive to participate. All that was left to race the Laser was to continue saving for a dry suit ($500 to $1,100), purchase a spare practice sail ($200) and practice sailing as much as possible this winter. If I found the time, I even planned on fixing the gel coat to make her pretty again...
My friends thought I was crazy but they don't see the world like I do. To me it was a sound plan: sound tested vessel I know intimately, light weight (65 kg) able to be beached easily with my current limitations, and unsinkable. Sure I was going to be wet but I was prepared for that and I knew that she could be safely sailed in up to 40 knot winds. I had even figured out how to wire her with solar panel and small LiFePO4 battery so that I could recharge radios, have navigational lights, etc. The beauty was that everything had been accounted for including the development of an inflatable tube that could be deployed along side the 3.8 m boat; so that if necessary, I could safely sleep aboard while rafted up to bull kelp or anchored off shore using a 2 kg claw anchor.
One friend thought it was crazy enough that he gave me his boat - the Etchells.
Now back to being a privateer... As a privateer, you race with what you have. Sure you have to be class legal and all but you make do. When I raced cars and bikes it was about whether you invested in new tires for the weekend to be competitive or whether you held off and made do with what you had. If you're serious and want to win, you buy the tires and eat ramen with foraged protein for the next month - ah youth... Every once in a while you get lucky - when I raced bikes, some shops would give you a discount on parts and an annual set of tires if you remained competitive and flew their decal on your bike. That was great if you simply wanted to participate but you couldn't win races without more resources. How does this relate to sailboat racing you may ask? It's the same thing - you make do with what you have, try and stay within the rules and do the best you can - or - you go commercial.
The rules for the R2AK are simple: no motors, hit these two checkpoints and don't make the Northwest Maritime Center (organizers) consult their lawyers. There are however the rules of the sea. This is a race that crosses borders. U.S. and Canadian Coast Guards interpreting SOLAS and the ColRegs have a lot to say on the operation of a vessel including basic equipment... The bigger the boat the more expensive the equipment and here's the rub for the privateer - how do I meet the rules using my given resources?
Remember my Etchells? She was designed to be dry stored and sailed by Yacht Club types not taken offshore in British Columbia nor Alaska. Her buoyancy chambers fore and aft have penetrations in them (adjustable forestay and backstays, etc.) as help is always near for the intended racers. Navigation lights? Not present... You get the idea, so with less than six months left to go, I'm figuring out how to make her sailable to Alaska and am having to figure out how to pay for it. Fortunately, I'm able to make many of my own modifications. Some, like sails however, come at a price that is way beyond my means ($400 for a storm jib and $1,300 for modifications to my best racing mainsail to make it usable in heavy winds) when I live on less than $100/mo disposable income. So what's the privateer to do? Well, seek sponsors...
Sponsors come in all shapes and sizes. Eagle Pipe and Mechanical (a friend and neighbor (2.5 km away)) has offered to help with some of the sail repairs in exchange for flying their logo - done! The other day I was out sailing and realized that all my blocks were manufactured by Harken and looking at my tiller extension (repurposed off the Laser), also Harken but best of all, was the cam cleat screwed to the prosthetic on the back of my arm for me to be able to pull more than 10 kg on lines - Harken! Now here's my idea, I still need blocks to make the Etchells really work for me, how about writing Harken and see if they'll kick in a pair of 57mm< quad and triple blocks so that I can reduce the load on my mainsheet or a used winch (none on the Etchells) so I can safely raise my halyards without wrapping the halyard lines around my body and hula hooping back and forth to get that last little bit! I'd gladly speak highly of their product as I've assimilated them into my daily life... I'll be borrowing a life raft and immersion suit. New rigging came care of my brother Jeff and a spool of Amsteel Blue. By the way the D-splicer (http://d-splicer.com) is the best for splicing 12 strand single braid line, but I digress...
So back to the larger issue of racing vs cruising... The folks at the Northwest Maritime Center have figured it out with the R2AK - it doesn't matter - doing is what matters! And this fits into the point I'm trying to make: know thyself (strengths and weaknesses), your vessel, and develop a plan to participate (race or cruise) as safely as possible (there are risks) but get out there and do it. You'll be glad you did.
For all those who want to travel vicariously to Ketchikan - send a small donation to Team Holding On, c/o Michael Adams, PO Box 65223, Port Ludlow, WA 98365 and I'll put your name on the side of the boat - now that's a privateer plan!
I'll also be documenting the trip in photos, audio and video and we'll see what comes of this... It may be useful for those that can't or won't find a way to do what others term, "crazy," but that makes life worth living.
All the best for now,
Michael
Last edited by TeamHangingOn on Fri Dec 25, 2015 6:40 pm, edited 4 times in total.
User avatar
TeamHangingOn
New Contributor
Posts: 13
Joined: Thu Nov 19, 2015 7:19 pm

Re: Racing vs Cruising

Post by TeamHangingOn »

Art:
Saw your post after I put up my last one...
When it's no longer fun, it's time to do something else.
In my last post I talked about professional racers - for them it's a job and they have to chase the trophies if they want to remain employable. I like to think of myself as a privateer... I do it for the enjoyment of trying to improve myself. Whether that's a better time, a better line, better sail trim, or just the, "I did that satisfaction," that one gets after participating.
With regard to being a single-hander. Me too! Partly, it's because I find so much peace when I'm on the water - I use it for pain management and my simple enjoyment. It could be blowing a gale and I'm out on the water comfortable in my element. It also entertains the neighbors when they see me out enjoying myself. I could take others, and do on occasion, but that's not where I find the greatest pleasure...
Happy sailing to you and a Merry Christmas!
Michael
Peter E
Major Contributor
Posts: 375
Joined: Fri Jun 24, 2011 1:17 pm
Location: USA Midwest Wis.

Re: Racing vs Cruising

Post by Peter E »

To me it is the journey not the destination. All my other boats have motors and I can go where I will but in sailing the wind is the master. This takes a different frame of mind. There is a skill in learning to use the wind and some times we want we want to compare our skill with some one else. That is all right but not a end all. In racing there is more than skill, hours can be spent finding that competitive edge all class boats are not the same. Subtle differences can make all the difference in racing weather it is in cars, bikes, or boats.
User avatar
Michel
Recognized Old Salt
Posts: 993
Joined: Thu Oct 07, 2010 6:25 pm

Re: Racing vs Cruising

Post by Michel »

To me, the journey is about being in the moment and being able to enjoy it. It is the reason why I am still happy after all these years with such a small and insignificant boat. As long as she pleases me by sailing well and she gives me some adventure, I'm perfectly OK. :) ( I still believe that a bigger boat will only bring me bigger troubles!...)

This short video shows very well what I am talking about.
https://youtu.be/NR7ua_1DR24

But a guy can prefer racing over anything else and that is again perfectly OK!
What makes you happy? ;)
Michel Boulet
Ex: "Mari-Bell" Sandpiper 565 (18.5367454 ft)
Now: "Papou" Tanzer 16 dinghy
Montreal
"Let the world say what it will"
~~_/)~~
Dirk Visser 166
Regular Contributor
Posts: 159
Joined: Tue Feb 24, 2015 11:47 am
Location: Fremont, Ca.
Contact:

Re: Racing vs Cruising

Post by Dirk Visser 166 »

Hey, Michel!, your short film made me happy just now, put me in your moment, and a few of my own as well. I get that this power to evoke peaceful feelings does not happen by accident, thank you for having the talent and desire to share it with us..
You could easily be the director of the film version of the Buckman book we are discussing on the adjoining thread!!
Post Reply