Addendum for "plans only" people

The place to discuss SCAMP (Small Craft Advisor Magazine Project), our 11' 11" micro minicruiser.

Moderator: Moderator

Post Reply
julie
Regular Contributor
Posts: 87
Joined: Fri Mar 30, 2012 8:49 pm
Location: Seattle, WA
Contact:

Re: Addendum for "plans only" people

Post by julie »

Monies wrote: One thing Mike usually does on boats is to loft onto plywood (cheap) and make patterns so he can play around with the layout of the pieces on the more expensive plywood. This allows optimization of materials and cuts down on both waste and materials.

I realize that this adds additional money/costs, additional labor, additional futzing around and does not lead to fast gratification of cutting wood and seeing a boat emerge!
I stole this idea from Mike, and I am very, very grateful that you shared the technique in the building thread 'SCAMP builds underway.'

As a plan builder and first time boat builder, I followed the pattern method. It did take longer, but it was absolutely worth it. As a complete novice and never having held a jigsaw before, my cuts were pretty clean by the time I was able to move over to the expensive plywood. Plus, it gave me extra time to really think over each piece. I would loft the pattern piece, then look it up in the build manual and read about where it'd go, how it'd be attached. By the time I went to install the piece, I had a pretty decent idea of what needed to be done and how it worked with the rest of the build.

If I'm blessed enough to be able to build another boat, I will definitely be using the pattern method!
Anders Bjorklund
Regular Contributor
Posts: 122
Joined: Sat Jan 15, 2011 12:06 pm

Re: Addendum for "plans only" people

Post by Anders Bjorklund »

How is the part shapes information presented in the plans? Are offsets from the ply edges provided so plans builders can easily plot all the points on each ply panel, connect the points with battens, cut out all those parts (or patterns), and then move on to the next ply panel?

I would think such offsets must have been provided to the CNC machine to cut out the kit parts, or could be easily derived from those inputs. No?


Anders
Anders Bjorklund
Regular Contributor
Posts: 122
Joined: Sat Jan 15, 2011 12:06 pm

Re: Addendum for "plans only" people

Post by Anders Bjorklund »

After reading this entire thread from the beginning, it appears that the plans builders posting here must be producing their long parts by joining large ply sheets together first, and then cutting out the entire parts in one piece from those panels. That's a straighforward method, but cutting the component pieces out first instead and then joining them later, often allows for a less wasteful use of plywood. In fact, I don't see why the CNC kit cut plan could not be also used by plans builders. But maybe I'm missing something.

It's true that more care then needs to be taken when the component pieces are joined, to ensure that the finished part will have the right length and shape. Full sized patterns can help, but a long reference line (stretched string) and some offset measurements are often enough to guarantee that. A couple of brads through the pieces into the work surface will keep things aligned and in position while clamping pressure is applied. Multiple kit parts that have the same shape can often be easily clamped together in one operation by stacking them up, with plastic sheets between them so they don't get epoxied to each other.

In the case of SCAMP, if the extra allowances for the puzzle joints on the CNC kit layout don't allow enough length for 8:1 scarph joints, butt joints can solve that problem, as several others have alrady said. Payson butt joints (a couple offset layers of glass tape on each side of the joints) are normally plenty strong. But prove it to yourself by bending some test joints to failure, to make sure that the failure occurs in the adjacent plywood instead of the joint. If the actual joint fails, try another layer of offset glass on each side of the joint. Wood or ply butt blocks would be another way to join them.

I keep thinking I must be overlooking something, so somebody will probably need to clue me in!

Cheers,
Anders
rklontz
New Contributor
Posts: 13
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 7:35 pm

Re: Addendum for "plans only" people

Post by rklontz »

I would say the majority of plans builders are using the kit nesting diagram and using Payson butt joints. I know Mike Monies uses and recomends this method.
SCAMP 181
Thorviking
Regular Contributor
Posts: 22
Joined: Sun Dec 02, 2012 7:43 am
Location: Spokane Valley, WA

Re: Addendum for "plans only" people

Post by Thorviking »

Having yet to scarf or execute a Payson butt joint, my ignorant bias is to note that a butt joint requires reducing the thickness, top and bottom, on both sides of the joint to accept a layer of glass. Whatever is gained by utilizing the butt joint, it seems to me, brings with it the chance to either leave too much meat, thereby leaving the glass proud of the surface, or to take out too much. These issues may not be deal breakers, but the Payson butt joint still takes some time to prepare while introducing the thickness variance at the joint I describe.

As to the suggestion to cut out the two pieces that then get scarfed or butted to produce a plank of the appropriate length, my continued ignorant bias can't help but think that an alignment challenge is created. It seems to me that the care necessary to keep the sweeping curve of the plank fair would negate some of the advantages of working with the two pieces that comprise the plank.

I'm going to proceed with scarfing half a sheet of okoume to the end of a full sheet and laying out paper templates of the planks to arrive at my own nesting plan. I was just hoping the nesting for the plans guys got squared away.

Rick

#151 "Scout"
Thorviking
Regular Contributor
Posts: 22
Joined: Sun Dec 02, 2012 7:43 am
Location: Spokane Valley, WA

Re: Addendum for "plans only" people

Post by Thorviking »

...or I could do it Mike Monies' way...;-)
rklontz
New Contributor
Posts: 13
Joined: Thu Jan 05, 2012 7:35 pm

Re: Addendum for "plans only" people

Post by rklontz »

Payson butt joints are simple and plenty strong for the scamp.
Here are some discussions about them,
http://smallcraftadvisor.com/message-bo ... lit=payson
http://smallcraftadvisor.com/message-bo ... lit=payson
SCAMP 181
User avatar
fred4win
Major Contributor
Posts: 447
Joined: Sun Jul 08, 2012 12:55 am
Location: Philippines

Re: Addendum for "plans only" people

Post by fred4win »

I also used the Payson method and it worked out very well with this design of boat. If you want to check out what the boat looks like from my post: Go back in time about a couple pages of the older post and you will find.

SCAMP Build #160 Under way w/pics

Page two of my post shows the Payson joints and page 4 and 5 show the finished product...after you paint them you cannot find the joints any longer...and you don't need to sand down the plywood for these joints before doing the glass.

Jackie the wife of Mike the Red SCAMP did it this way and recommended to me...Glad I did and the boat is strong as a rock...You try to break the joint after you make one and you will be a believer like me. The curve of the planks are perfect for the Payson but joints to fit together....I had no Problem with them at all...Payson method was so easy...... I will never use the scarfing method again...much to complicated.

I will post a few pics here to check out for yourself.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Winning is for every thing losing is for nothing
Monies
Recognized Old Salt
Posts: 805
Joined: Sat Nov 20, 2010 8:39 pm

Re: Addendum for "plans only" people

Post by Monies »

Found some photos in my files of the joints which show they are clean, not heavy.

Jackie Monies- The Red Scamp
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Anders Bjorklund
Regular Contributor
Posts: 122
Joined: Sat Jan 15, 2011 12:06 pm

Re: Addendum for "plans only" people

Post by Anders Bjorklund »

Rick, which ever way you go is going to take some time and fiddling. Using the CNC kit panel layouts and individual butt joints would save you some plywood and is not a big deal. I recently scarphed and aligned all the planks on two stitch and glue touring kayaks. It was easy to do and the sweeps and lengths of the planks all came out spot on. In fact, if I were building from a kit, I wouldn't completely trust the puzzle joints to automatically produce the precise amount of curvature in the planks. A tight string and a couple of quick offset measurements is enough to make sure everything is lined up as it should be.

Payson joints would be even easier than scarphs to align, and it isn't hard to finish them to a uniform thickness, which makes them as invisible as scarph joints. It's actually easier to make butt joints look good under varnish in comparison to scarphs, where the joints can look slightly wavy or ragged after they are sanded smooth.

But if buying a couple extra sheets of plywood doesn't bother you, pre-scarphing extra length onto the 4x8' sheets would also be a good way to go. You would have to do your own nesting plan and you would have more scrap left over. But having extra ply available can often come in handy too.

Anders


Thorviking wrote:Having yet to scarf or execute a Payson butt joint, my ignorant bias is to note that a butt joint requires reducing the thickness, top and bottom, on both sides of the joint to accept a layer of glass. Whatever is gained by utilizing the butt joint, it seems to me, brings with it the chance to either leave too much meat, thereby leaving the glass proud of the surface, or to take out too much. These issues may not be deal breakers, but the Payson butt joint still takes some time to prepare while introducing the thickness variance at the joint I describe.

As to the suggestion to cut out the two pieces that then get scarfed or butted to produce a plank of the appropriate length, my continued ignorant bias can't help but think that an alignment challenge is created. It seems to me that the care necessary to keep the sweeping curve of the plank fair would negate some of the advantages of working with the two pieces that comprise the plank.

I'm going to proceed with scarfing half a sheet of okoume to the end of a full sheet and laying out paper templates of the planks to arrive at my own nesting plan. I was just hoping the nesting for the plans guys got squared away.

Rick

#151 "Scout"
Post Reply